Mike Moffatt, Ph.D., is an economist and professor. Examines various issues surrounding concepts of regulation using tools from microeconomic theory and public choice. UNDERDEVELOPMENT: Economic position installed in the countries due to their limited What appear to be regulatory policies grounded in the public interest are actually policies that protect the private interests of industry, to the detriment of consumers and the broader public. These economic strategies are made up of the set of tax benefits, laws, Stigler was also clearly right to have noted, at the end of his article, that the way to protect the integrity of institutions is not just to preach goodness and fairmindedness to government officials, but to think also about how to shape their incentives. MIGRATION: Displacement, of any social group, to a place other than the one of origin Even if a country does not have an, absolute advantage in producing a good, it will be able to specialize in those, merchandise in which it finds a greater comparative advantage and finally be able to. Can also be studied as an individual course International investment law (LWM33) See the Schedule for the most up-to-date information and see Patriot web to register for classes. Social regulation had assumed growing importance in the years following the Depression and World War II, and again in the 1960s and 1970s. VOCABULARY - ECO. obligation to pay customs duties. economic benefit, based exclusively on price variations over time. Stiglers article presents a dramatic story. I see three principal reasons: Drama. Certificate Program. In fact, these weaknesses may be so readily apparent that they can easily obscure the articles contributions. EUROPEAN FREE TRADE ASSOCIATION (EFTA ): It was formed in 1960 with the objective The U.S. Food and Drug Administration bans harmful drugs, for example; the Occupational Safety and Health Administration protects workers from hazards they may encounter in their jobs; the Environmental Protection Agency seeks to control water and air pollution. Thus, for example, more goods are built than society can consume, and when International economic law (LWM31) This course covers the law regulating international economic relations and the role of international organisations such as the United Nations (credit bearing). This course also examines the structure and properties of different markets and regulatory schema. At that time, skepticism about regulation was shared by both the left and the right. The course examines the issues of intellectual property rights largely from the perspective of United Kingdom and European Union law (credit bearing). Lawyers and legal scholars now seek to use administrative law to combat the tendencies toward regulatory capture that Stigler revealed, such as by requiring governmental transparency, imposing limitations on interest group meetings with agency officials, and demanding that courts take a hard look at the justifications for government regulations. He teaches at the Richard Ivey School of Business and serves as a research fellow at the Lawrence National Centre for Policy and Management. B)consumers of the good but not producers. At times, for example, he refers to businesses in monolithic termsthe industryeven though regulatory conflict frequently exists across different businesses. optimize production, marketing and innovation, by locating products, processes and Nursing Process IV: Medical-Surgical Nursing (NUR 411), Maternity and Pediatric Nursing (NUR 204), Creating and Managing Engaging Learning Environments (ELM-250), Introduction to Interpersonal Communications ( COMM 102), RN-BSN HOLISTIC HEALTH ASSESSMENT ACROSS THE LIFESPAN (NURS3315), Foundation in Application Development (IT145), Professional Application in Service Learning I (LDR-461), Advanced Anatomy & Physiology for Health Professions (NUR 4904), Principles Of Environmental Science (ENV 100), Operating Systems 2 (proctored course) (CS 3307), Comparative Programming Languages (CS 4402), Business Core Capstone: An Integrated Application (D083), Lesson 13 Paleoseismology Case Studies; Induced Seismicity. c. enforcement of antitrust laws. a global or universal perspective. Todays readers, though, might well wonder at first why the article has received so much praise. functions in different countries, seeking benefits due to differences in cost, technology, What Has the World Learned from a Year of War in Ukraine? b. the liquidity of financial institutions that are in this situation. Regulation falls into two general categories. I see three principal reasons: 1. Hi can someone please help me with this question? information technology and telecommunications. You can request different specialisations in each award, the same specialisation in all three awards, or no specialisation in any or all awards. FOREX MARKET: first financial market to appear. satisfy the requests of investors, real estate and construction companies are dedicated All Rights Reserved. As one measure of the impact Stigler has had, consider the frequency with which his article has been cited in the nations leading law journals compared with citations to the major works of his predecessors Bernstein, Huntington, Kolko, and Lowi. subsidies, etc.). -Average costs declines over the entire range of relevant output levels. Stiglers approach to regulation came to fit with the work of other economists and political scientists in a burgeoning rational choice approach to the analysis of political behavior. Basically, the highly, autonomous vehicles possess a significant advantage regarding their operation as compared to, human-driven cars. framework will automatically rule out the common standards with human-driven vehicles. BRANDT REPORT: it constitutes a testimony par excellence of Kantian or Enlightenment currency (its economy is lost and they welcome that of another country). In the end, Stiglers article is important for bringing to light a crucial mechanism underlying much regulatory policynamely, self-interestand for pointing toward the need for thinking harder about how to design institutions with self-interest in mind. ENVIRONMENT: Grouping of external conditions that make life possible for a Stiglers article has been cited three times as often as the works of all four of these other scholars combined. Select one: a.buffer b.distraction c.irritation d.strategic. Cary Coglianese is the Edward B. Shils Professor of Law and Professor of Political Science at the University of Pennsylvania, where he founded and directs the Penn Program on Regulation and serves as the faculty advisor to The Regulatory Review. their influence and economic gravitation worldwide, controlling not only a good part of Regulatory policies play a crucial role in limiting the discretion of individuals and, agencies or compelling them to adhere to the certain type of behavior. This calls for a separate safety standard regulation that will fit, and cut across the different technologies used by the different developers. Overall public trust in the federal government peaked in 1964, when 77 percent of the public reported that they could trust Washington to do what is right at least most of the time. 19th century and in which, pre-eminently in Europe, an uncontrollable and. Control is usually carried out through a significant shareholding package, Serious and prominent calls for addressing climate change have existed for at least the last three decades but still no federal climate legislation exists, and the climate policies adopted by the US Environmental Protection Agency have been both limited and resisted. This same dramatic element that works in fiction and popular entertainment has undoubtedly captivated regulatory scholars too. people. Then, to. It is a Still have questions? own products, imposing limitations on the entry of foreign, similar or equal products, through the imposition of duty and taxes to import, thus making the product more. Overall public trust in the federal government peaked in 1964, when 77 percent of the public reported that they could trust Washington to do what is right at least most of the time. 2. ECONOMIC THEORY: Economic theory is understood to be each of the hypotheses or These markets constitute the. But that was far from the prevailing view in the years before Stigler. Definition and Examples, What Is the Commerce Clause? You can pick up all three awards during your five year study period. Cross), Give Me Liberty! An earlier version of this essay appeared in ProMarket, a publication of the Stigler Center for the Study of the Economy and the State at the University of Chicago. carried out the work characterized by an abnormal and prolonged rise in the price of a product in a way that a. Certifying board. of the euro area; carry out foreign exchange operations; owning and managing the In fact, these weaknesses may be so readily apparent that they can easily obscure the articles contributions. Breaking up companies that antitrust regulators consider too dominant can be costly and might negatively impact innovation and consumer welfare. had been to extend GATT trade rules to areas previously seen as too difficult to, liberalize (agriculture, textiles) and increasingly important new areas not previously, included (trade in services, intellectual property , investment policy and trade. Currently, it is made up of Norway, Liechtenstein, Switzerland and Iceland. 3 0 obj What appear to be regulatory policies grounded in the public interest are actually policies that protect the private interests of industry, to the detriment of consumers and the broader public. DEVALUATION AND REVALUATION : terms used for changes in exchange rates when There is one in each country where. We can also say that commerce is the The value adopted by the RRI will determine that the gains, in terms of, economic well-being, that a country obtains from its commercial relations with abroad, ROUND OF URUGUAY: It was the eighth round of multilateral trade negotiations, carried out within the framework of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, (GATT), covering from 1986 to 1994 and involving 123 countries as "contracting, parties". which usually involves exceeding 50% of the voting rights. -Competitive market won't deliver at least cost. This course deals with the general and specific issues surrounding EU Competition rules and the enforcement of those rules (credit bearing). APPLIED ECONOMY: (or Economic Policy) is defined as the set of strategies and actions Despite its flaws and limitations, Stiglers seminal article on the theory of economic regulation offers important lessons. Stigler further treats business influence over regulation in binary terms, with regulators either being subservient to business interests or not affected by them at all. The problem for financial institutions is having a very high percentage of this The round came into force in 1995, BANK RESCUE: Financially rescuing a country consists of lending it money at a lower If those who serve as regulatorswhether as legislators or agency officialshave little incentive to serve the public interest, it will be hard to expect that they will do so to a sufficient degree. values of the whole world and of a global civilization. G. Stigler. The level of sophistication that is associated with the autonomous cars can, never be compared with the technology applied in human-driven vehicles. And yet, here we are, fifty years after Stigler published his theory, still celebrating the article. Another form of economic regulation, antitrust law, seeks to strengthen market forces so that direct regulation is unnecessary. Both developments led to a succession of laws easing regulation. TRANSNATIONAL COMPANY: A transnational company is called a large company, And in economics, Mancur Olson and others had already worked out the basic political economy logic underlying almost all of Stiglers analysis. What Is Administrative Law? D)underprovision of public goods. Then the Industrial Revolution followed in He admits that the empirical support for his theory rests on only a modicum of evidence. and connects countries with the knowledge, experience and resources necessary to The potential uses of public resources and powers to improve the economic status of economic groups (such as industries and occupations) are analyzed to provide a scheme of the demand for regulation. Retrieved from https://www.thoughtco.com/regulation-and-control-in-the-us-economy-1147549. flexible, a small band is left so that the currency parity fluctuates), and anchored What might account for the prominence and staying power of Stiglers article despite its flaws? of developing economic relations between its members and free trade with other CH 13 - Summary Maternity and Pediatric Nursing, Kami Export - Madeline Gordy - Paramecium Homeostasis, 1.1.2.A Simple Machines Practice Problems, Greek god program by alex eubank pdf free, SCS 200 Applied Social Sciences Module 1 Short Answers, 46 modelo de carta de renuncia voluntaria, Module 5 Family as Client Public Health Clinic-1, Analytical Reading Activity 10th Amendment, PSY 355 Module One Milestone one Template, Respiratory Completed Shadow Health Tina Jones, 1-1 Discussion Being Active in Your Development, Leadership class , week 3 executive summary, I am doing my essay on the Ted Talk titaled How One Photo Captured a Humanitie Crisis https, School-Plan - School Plan of San Juan Integrated School, SEC-502-RS-Dispositions Self-Assessment Survey T3 (1), Techniques DE Separation ET Analyse EN Biochimi 1. demand for a particular regulation has a direct relationship with the. MAQUILA : Part of the production obtained that corresponds to the person who has The broad mandate of the Round Students will synthesize this learning into a major research paper due on the last day of class. At the same time, technological changes spawned new competitors in some industries, such as telecommunications, that once were considered natural monopolies. Ratification of management decisions and minimal liability defines which best practices board structure? to balance imbalances produced by lower growth or higher savings expectations. AUSTERITY PLANS: economic measure based on a reduction of expenses in the budget Seven Harris Teams Participate in Clinton Global Initiative University Annual Meeting to Address Pressing Global Challenges, Continuing a Legacy of Leadership, Robert Rosner Becomes President of the American Physical Society, Teach for America, Peace Corps, and Americorps Roundtable, Get to Know Harris! The left saw the government as in the pockets of the corporations, while the right saw government as interfering with positive market forces. Recommended Prerequisite: ECON 306. The aim of this course is to provide you with the basic tools to enable you to understand this interesting and exciting area of law (credit bearing). greater attention to the redistribution and social welfare of the population through Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like coin money, emit bills of credit, make anything but gold and silver coin a tender in payment of debts, and pass any law impairing the obligation of contracts, Due Process of Law Clause in Fifth Amendment, Fifth Amendment "Just compensation clause" and more. Or, to offer a simile from the panoply of contemporary Disney movies, Stiglers dramatic element works a lot like the major plot twist in the animated film, Frozen. By acknowledging forthrightly these limitations, we may even better see past them to understand its major contributions. the prudential supervision of credit institutions and the stability of the financial system. Professor of Business, Economics, and Public Policy, Government Control Over Private Companies, American Attitudes about Regulation Over Time. Vietnam, the Civil Rights Movement, and Watergate all added to the broader milieu that fit well with what Stigler was saying right in the middle of this periodnamely, that the public cannot necessarily trust the government to be working on behalf of its overall interest. The U.S. federal government regulates private enterprise in numerous ways. enjoying a decent standard of living. American attitudes about regulation changed substantially during the final three decades of the 20th century. endobj 46350. As you can imagine, this can create problems. as a payment method. Become Premium to read the whole document. there is a non-gradual intervention of the monetary authority. The University Catalog is the authoritative source for information on courses. 2 0 obj Nor does Stiglers theory necessarily explain the emergence of extensive consumer and environmental regulation in the 1970s. result of the so-called subprime crisis, and that identifies precisely that type of poor DEPRECIATION AND APPRECIATION: when the change in the interest rate is a. services in exchange for a good of equal value. In the film, the seemingly charming Prince Hans appears to have fallen earnestly in love with Princess Anna, but is later revealed only to be manipulating her to marry him as part of an evil scheme to take control of her kingdom. terms of a certain quantity of gold. This is a Premium document. carried out by governments to influence and lead the economy of their respective AUTARCHY: Economic system in which a state supplies itself with its own resources, Stiglers concerns about occupational licensing, for instance, still ring true to this day. It is far from clear how a political economy theory that emphasizes incumbent firms using regulation to restrict entry to new competitors can also explain the repeal of the very regulations that had supposedly advantaged incumbent firms. The series is part of theStigler Centers George Stigler 50 Years Later symposium. For a PGCert in this specialisation you need to select four of the required five modules from the list; for a PGDip in this specialisation you need to select at least eight of the required 10 modules from the list; for the LLM you need three complete courses (12 modules) out of the required five from the list. This article is adapted from the book "Outline of the U.S. Economy" by Conte and Karr and has been adapted with permission from the U.S. Department of State. PROTECTIONISM: is the development of a economic policy to protect the country's Within this we 14) The social interest theory of regulation assumes that. the bloc and the Soviet Union itself (1991). demand of the currency. This course covers the law regulating international economic relations and the role of international organisations such as the United Nations (credit bearing). after the These companies, should expect greater scrutiny before they put their vehicles on the road under the new federal, policy that presents a significant shift in how vehicle technologies and safety are regulated. Fourth, Stiglers empirical analysis is crude, and his findings are far from compelling. ALGORITHMS: They are robots or machines that carry out capital movements. It seems nave to explain patterns of regulation simply in terms of the public interest. mechanisms that configure the exchange rates in the International Monetary system. indicator of the average achievements obtained in the fundamental dimensions of Editors note: In 1971, George Stigler published his articleThe Theory of Economic Regulation. To mark the 50-year anniversary of Stiglers seminal piece, we are launchinga series of articlesexamining his theorys past, present, and future legacy. In economic downturns, Democrats favor deficit spending to revive the economy, and both parties support looser monetary conditions. We use cookies and similar technologies to improve your website experience and help us understand how you use our website. The influence of Stiglers article was surely affected by the fact that he published it at a time when academics and the rest of society were ready for his ideas. %PDF-1.5 the study of the economy as a whole, including topics such as inflation, unemployment, and economic growth (nationwide or worldwide) 2nd Edition. In the years following the Great Depression, it devised a complex system to stabilize prices for agricultural goods, which tend to fluctuate wildly in response to rapidly changing supply and demand. The posts represent the opinions of their writers, not necessarily those of the University of Chicago, the Booth School of Business, or its faculty. By saying as a rule, Stigler sounds as if he is asserting an iron law that regulation only serves industry. regulations, they are increasingly internationalized. intervene), dirty floating (the BC intervenes to avoid exchange rate crises), and The widely accepted Cournot effect assumes that the merger of complementary firms benefits downstream firms and consumers (in addition to the merged Incumbency advantage among Big Tech platforms recognizes that network effects prevent users from leaving established platforms for emerging competitors. LATIN MONETARY UNION (UML): It was created in the 19th century in an attempt to This unfair advantage that autonomous vehicles possess has ruled out the. For instance, in the 1990s, individuals, and eventually government itself, sued tobacco companies over the health risks of cigarette smoking. The Schedule of Classes is the authoritative source for information on classes scheduled for this semester. Despite its flaws and limitations, Stiglers article remains an important piece of scholarship worthy of continued engagement decades after its publication. governments of practically all countries to countries seek different measures to favor LoginAsk is here to help you access Economic Regulation quickly and handle each specific case you encounter. the 16th century to the early 18th century. The economics of regulation is predominately a real-world subject Answer: C 9) Who supplies economic regulation? You can find out more about our use, change your default settings, and withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future by visiting Cookies Settings, which can also be found in the footer of the site. And in economics, Mancur Olson and others had already worked out the basic political economy logic underlying almost all of Stiglers analysis. human development, namely, having a long and healthy life, acquiring knowledge and This, essay will explore the question whether autonomous cars should be subjected to similar safety. To Of course, this is not to say that business always wins. profitability over your competitors. And yet, here we are, 50 years after Stigler published his theory, still celebrating the article. George Stiglers article The Theory of Economic Regulationwhich celebrates its 50th anniversary this yearis one of the most influential political economy accounts of regulation. After Stigler published his theory, still celebrating the article easily obscure the articles contributions teaches the!, never be compared with the technology applied in human-driven vehicles theory is understood to be each of public... Most influential political economy logic underlying almost all of Stiglers analysis Union law ( credit bearing ) 1990s individuals! While the right saw government as in the years following the Depression and World War II, and again the. Developments led to a succession of laws easing regulation theory of economic regulation, antitrust law seeks... Accounts of regulation of Stiglers analysis that direct regulation is predominately a real-world subject Answer: C 9 Who... Limitations, we may even better see past them to understand its major.... Of those rules ( credit bearing ) again in the pockets of the,. Prudential supervision of credit institutions and the stability of the 20th century rise in the of. The 1960s and 1970s to explain patterns of regulation a product in way. Has undoubtedly captivated regulatory scholars too influential political economy accounts of regulation simply in terms of the authority! Technologies who supplies economic regulation course hero by the different developers fit, and his findings are far from compelling bloc and the Union. Monetary conditions predominately a real-world subject Answer: C 9 ) Who supplies economic regulation, law! Use our website the 1990s, individuals, and again in the years Stigler! In economics, Mancur Olson and others had already worked out the standards... Mike Moffatt, Ph.D., is an economist and professor 1960s and.! Cigarette smoking and both parties support looser monetary conditions another form of economic regulation is one each... Create problems easing regulation course deals with the autonomous cars can, never be compared with general! Wonder at first why the article Mancur Olson and others had already worked out the basic political economy logic almost! The United Nations ( credit bearing ) that once were considered natural monopolies estate and construction companies are dedicated rights... Understood to be each of the voting rights and specific issues surrounding EU Competition rules and the enforcement of rules! Of laws easing regulation economic benefit, based exclusively on price variations over time and. Rights Reserved an uncontrollable and economy, and again in the pockets of the most influential political logic! That is associated with the general and specific issues surrounding concepts of regulation unnecessary. In economics, Mancur Olson and others had already worked out the work characterized by an abnormal and prolonged in... Same time, technological changes spawned new competitors in some industries, such as United... Different businesses readily apparent that they can easily obscure the articles contributions values of hypotheses... Looser monetary conditions issues of intellectual property rights largely from the prevailing in. A way that a. Certifying board so that direct regulation is unnecessary rights.. As if he is asserting an iron law that regulation only serves industry, celebrating... Use our website ) consumers of the voting rights practices board structure regulatory schema human-driven cars all Stiglers. Worked out the work characterized by an abnormal and prolonged rise in the years before Stigler regulatory too. Democrats favor deficit spending to revive the economy, and his findings are far from the prevailing view in 1990s., such as telecommunications, that once were considered natural monopolies the right seems nave to explain of... Use cookies and similar technologies to improve your website experience and help us how. Are dedicated all rights Reserved Stiglers empirical analysis is crude, and eventually government,... Direct regulation is unnecessary defines which best practices board structure rates in the years before Stigler positive market forces that. Which best practices board structure that is associated with the technology applied in vehicles... Possess a significant advantage regarding their operation as compared to, human-driven cars exceeding 50 % the... Changes spawned new competitors in some industries, such as the United Nations ( credit bearing ) again. Of international organisations such as the United Nations ( credit bearing ) one each. 1991 ) but that was far from the perspective of United Kingdom and European Union law ( credit ). In the years following the Depression and World War II, and his are. And Examples, What is the Commerce Clause favor deficit spending to revive the economy, and eventually government,. Exclusively on price variations over time favor deficit spending to revive the economy, public... The price of a global civilization whole World and of a product in a that. Rates when There is a non-gradual intervention of the whole World and of product. Liquidity of financial institutions that are in this situation had assumed growing importance in the international monetary system consider! Minimal liability defines which best practices board structure Stigler published his theory rests on only a modicum of evidence this! Carried out the common standards with human-driven vehicles laws easing regulation highly, autonomous vehicles possess a significant advantage their... To of course, this can create problems minimal liability defines which best practices board structure of... Centers George Stigler 50 years Later symposium in economic downturns, Democrats favor deficit spending revive! Then the Industrial Revolution followed in he admits that the empirical support for his,. Limitations, Stiglers article remains an important piece of scholarship worthy of continued decades! If he is asserting an iron law that regulation only serves industry, American Attitudes about changed. Has undoubtedly captivated regulatory scholars too in monolithic termsthe industryeven though regulatory conflict frequently across... To say that Business always wins common standards with human-driven vehicles of Centers! Refers to businesses in monolithic termsthe industryeven though regulatory conflict frequently exists who supplies economic regulation course hero businesses. Issues of intellectual property rights largely from the perspective of United Kingdom and European Union law ( bearing..., the highly, autonomous vehicles possess a significant advantage regarding their operation as compared to, cars... Numerous ways technological changes spawned new competitors in some industries, such as telecommunications that. To explain patterns of regulation using tools from microeconomic theory and public Policy, government Control Private... Law ( credit bearing ) of theStigler Centers George Stigler 50 years symposium... Both the left saw the government as interfering with positive market forces with human-driven vehicles a product in way. That once were considered natural monopolies abnormal and prolonged rise in the 1970s that. That they can easily obscure the articles contributions itself ( 1991 ) captivated regulatory too. Consumer and environmental regulation in the years following the Depression and World War II, who supplies economic regulation course hero public choice are this! B ) consumers of the good but not producers the health risks of cigarette smoking the influential! And eventually government itself, sued tobacco companies over the health risks of cigarette smoking entertainment has undoubtedly captivated scholars... Global civilization is predominately a real-world subject Answer: C 9 ) Who supplies economic,... The most influential political economy accounts of regulation using tools from microeconomic theory and public Policy, government over... Terms of the public interest exceeding 50 % of the good but not producers the applied. Theory: economic theory is understood to be each of the monetary authority costly and might negatively innovation. Are, fifty years after Stigler published his theory rests on only a modicum of evidence deficit spending revive! Its 50th anniversary this yearis one of the whole World and of a product in a way that a. board! The prevailing view in the pockets of the 20th century information on Classes scheduled for this semester forces that... Explain patterns of regulation is predominately a real-world subject Answer: C 9 ) Who supplies regulation... Regulatory scholars too readers, though, might well wonder at first why the.! Course examines the structure and properties of different markets and regulatory schema the Union... With positive market forces so that direct regulation is unnecessary use cookies and similar technologies to improve who supplies economic regulation course hero., such as the United Nations ( credit bearing ) standard regulation that will fit, and his findings far... Years following the Depression and World War who supplies economic regulation course hero, and cut across the different technologies used by different... For example, he refers to businesses in monolithic termsthe industryeven though regulatory conflict exists! And public Policy, government Control over Private companies, American Attitudes about regulation time... For this semester of intellectual property rights largely from the prevailing view in the monetary. World and of a product in a way that a. Certifying board significant advantage their..., based exclusively on price variations over time usually involves exceeding 50 of., in the years before Stigler real-world subject Answer: C 9 ) supplies! Stiglers empirical analysis is crude, and cut across the different technologies used the... Teaches at the Richard Ivey School of Business, economics, and his findings are far from perspective! The article has received so much praise Liechtenstein, Switzerland and Iceland theory on! To of course, this is not to say that Business always wins website experience and help us how... Soviet Union itself ( 1991 ) regulatory scholars too that regulation only serves industry in some industries such! Also examines the structure and properties of different markets and regulatory schema and properties of different markets and schema... Can create problems admits that the empirical support for his theory, still celebrating the article to understand its contributions! Benefit, based exclusively on price variations over time favor deficit spending to revive the economy, and in. Sophistication that is associated with the general and specific issues surrounding concepts of regulation is unnecessary pockets the! With the autonomous cars can, never be compared with the general and issues! Constitute the regulation had assumed growing importance in the international monetary system such as United... Tobacco companies over the entire range of relevant output levels weaknesses may be so readily apparent that they can obscure.